Oklahoma Supreme Court rules against petition for COVID-19 precautions at Trump rally

The Oklahoma Supreme Court denied a legal petition Friday requiring attendees at President Donald Trump’s Saturday campaign rally in Tulsa to observe social distancing protocols and wear face masks.

Tulsa attorneys Clark Brewster and Paul DeMuro filed the lawsuit, along with an emergency petition for an injunction Tuesday, on behalf of the Greenwood Centre, the John Hope Franklin Center for Reconciliation and two individuals, against ASM Global, parent company of the firm that manages the BOK Center in Tulsa, where the president’s rally will take place.

In a unanimous decision Friday afternoon, the court ruled the petitioners did not “possess a clear legal right to the relief they seek,” since Phase 3 of the governor’s Open Up and Recover Safely (OURS) Plan allows business owners, including large venues, to use their own discretion in “determining the appropriate levels of social distancing and group size.”

Absent any other restrictive guidelines, the court stated in its judgment the BOK Center needed only to follow the OURS Plan.

“Therefore,” they wrote, “for a lack of any mandatory language in the OURS Plan, we are compelled to deny the relief requested.”

The petitioners, which included two immunocompromised Tulsans, stated in their filing they sought relief due to the risks of a large gathering during an “alarming uptick in COVID-19 infections in Tulsa County,” and sought to “protect against a substantial, imminent, and deadly risk to the community.”

On Monday, Tulsa County reported an increase rate of COVID-19 cases of more than 16% — its highest rate of new cases since the pandemic started, according to the court filing.

Having an indoor rally under those conditions would constitute a “super-spreader” event in downtown Tulsa, the petitioners claimed.

Brewster posted a comment on his Facebook page Friday expressing disappointment the court had taken a narrow reading of the guidelines in the OURS Plan to allow a large gathering during the pandemic.

“On behalf of our clients, who as plaintiffs filed this action and sought protection from the Supreme Court of Oklahoma, we are deeply disappointed that the Court could not, amongst themselves, reach the merits of the plaintiff’s claims,” Brewster wrote. “Such a technical application of the law potentially leaves many citizens who participate, or who later closely associate with attendees, exposed to the COVID-19 viral spread, illness and death.”

Brewster said no further appeals will be filed in the case “due to the closeness of time to the start of the Trump rally.”

News

Athens makes a splash with groundbreaking of Sunrise Park

More Stories

Gov. Ivey signs a pair of senate bills into law

News

Commission approves agreement for roadway improvements at Pryor Field

More Stories

Alabama’s road conditions ranked second best in the United States

More Stories

Gov. Ivey commutes death sentence for 1991 Decatur murder prisoner

More Stories

42nd Alabama State Games registration opens

More Stories

Alabama Republican Party re-elects John Wahl as Chairman

More Stories

Warning siren failure in Limestone County

News

‘Great things ahead’: Mayor Marks shares insights on city’s future in annual address

More Stories

Grammy-nominated singer Angie Stone dies in Montgomery car crash

More Stories

Limestone County outdoor warning sirens malfunctioning

News

Melson disputes patient’s version of conversation regarding purchasing medical cannabis ‘off the street’

More Stories

Homeland Security recognizes ALEA as Partner of the Year

More Stories

Athens earns 2024 Tree City USA recognition from Arbor Day Foundation

More Stories

Teacher of the Year: Anna Thompson

News

‘Justice was served’: Limestone County jury finds Morgan County man guilty of murder after 10-day trial

News

Brookyln’s brave battle: The inspiring journey of a local kids life with spinal muscular atrophy

More Stories

Teacher of the Year: Jennie Fullmer

More Stories

Teacher of the Year: Kaitlin Sparkman

More Stories

Ardmore welcomes new family medicine center

More Stories

Hit and run claims life of Athens man

More Stories

LCSO arrest Athens man for infant abuse

News

Final Curtain Call: Beloved Band Director Dan Havely passes away

News

Calhoun Community College to go virtual due to impending weather