Sheriff’s Office seeks leads on cold case

Tuesday marked 14 years since two fishermen discovered the body of Noelle Virginia McAnally in Piney Creek.

Autopsy results showed the 26-year-old Huntsville woman’s remains had been there at least five days. She died from blunt-force trauma and was identified through dental records.

Limestone County Sheriff Mike Blakely said at the time some of McAnally’s clothing was found in the water. One of her tennis shoes was found hanging from a tree near the Piney Creek bridge.

The Limestone County Sheriff’s Office is still seeking information about the cold case. Her death has been investigated by both the Sheriff’s Office and Huntsville Police Department since authorities believe she may have been murdered there.

In April, Gov. Kay Ivey renewed a $5,000 reward for the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible for McAnally’s death. Law enforcement officers hope the reward, combined with a plea for information, will produce some new leads.

“We’re trying to bring some information to it,” said Deputy Stephen Young, public information officer for the Sheriff’s Office.

At the time of McAnally’s death, she had a 5-year-old daughter.

“All she’s known since then is pictures (of her mother),” Young said. “The family needs some closure on the case.”

About the case

McAnally had been divorced for about a year and was living with a man in an apartment complex in the 2300 block of Bob Wallace Avenue in Huntsville.

Her death may be connected to three unsolved homicides in Huntsville, authorities said.

The three women frequented an area of Hall Street, a hangout for the homeless and prostitutes. Authorities said McAnally was not a prostitute, but she took rides with strangers and often stayed in rescue missions.

She was last seen Memorial Day weekend. Her ex-husband, who is also the father of her daughter, filed a missing person report with the Huntsville Police Department.

Anyone with information about the case is asked to contact Limestone County Sheriff’s Investigator Rodney McAbee at 256-216-5022 or rmcabee@limestonesheriff.com.

— WAFF-48 contributed to this report.

News

April is Autism Acceptance Month

Local News

Health reports March 29, 2025

News

Shop local, invest in Athens: Local commerce fuels community growth

Local News

APD makes arrest in hit-and-run involving pedestrian

More Stories

Daikin funds scholarships for future technicians at Calhoun

More Stories

Agricultural relief payments may keep farmers afloat

News

Athens makes a splash with groundbreaking of Sunrise Park

More Stories

Gov. Ivey signs a pair of senate bills into law

News

Commission approves agreement for roadway improvements at Pryor Field

More Stories

Alabama’s road conditions ranked second best in the United States

More Stories

Gov. Ivey commutes death sentence for 1991 Decatur murder prisoner

More Stories

42nd Alabama State Games registration opens

More Stories

Alabama Republican Party re-elects John Wahl as Chairman

More Stories

Warning siren failure in Limestone County

News

‘Great things ahead’: Mayor Marks shares insights on city’s future in annual address

More Stories

Grammy-nominated singer Angie Stone dies in Montgomery car crash

More Stories

Limestone County outdoor warning sirens malfunctioning

News

Melson disputes patient’s version of conversation regarding purchasing medical cannabis ‘off the street’

More Stories

Homeland Security recognizes ALEA as Partner of the Year

More Stories

Athens earns 2024 Tree City USA recognition from Arbor Day Foundation

More Stories

Teacher of the Year: Anna Thompson

News

‘Justice was served’: Limestone County jury finds Morgan County man guilty of murder after 10-day trial

News

Brookyln’s brave battle: The inspiring journey of a local kids life with spinal muscular atrophy

More Stories

Teacher of the Year: Jennie Fullmer