Trial date set for ex-Athens man in Nashville murders

An October trial date is tentatively set for a former Athens man accused in a double murder in Nashville.

Court records show Brandon Griswold, 21, is scheduled to stand trial Oct. 10 in Davidson County, Tennessee, though the trial date could change, said Mike Roland, the Nashville detective who investigated the case.

Griswold and his girlfriend, 23-year-old Whitney Gray, formerly of Oklahoma, are accused in the Sept. 21, 2015, murders of 24-year-old Preston Claybrooks and his longtime girlfriend 23-year-old Alexandra Grubbs, with whom Gray and Griswold lived at Howe Garden Apartments on Nashville’s east side.

Roland testified in 2015 that he believed Gray and Griswold killed the couple to avoid repaying a $650 heroin debt.

Gray’s trial date is tentatively scheduled for Sept. 25, though it also could be changed.

“Those things are never solid because there is always the chance of plea bargaining or postponement of a trial,” Roland said.

Both Gray and Griswold are formally charged with two counts of first-degree murder, two counts of felony murder, two counts of abuse of a corpse, tampering with evidence and theft over $500.

The state, as represented by the Davidson County District Attorney’s Office, is seeking life without possibility of parole, court records show.

Roland said seeking the death penalty requires a lot more preparation.

The case

According to a story in The Tennessean newspaper, Roland testified Gray used a hammer and Griswold a microphone stand to beat their roommates as they slept the morning of Sept. 21. The victims also had their throats cut, he said. Gray and Griswold then wrapped their bodies like mummies with sheets and blankets and put them in a utility closet.

Claybrooks’ mother went to the apartment Sept. 26, after reporting her son missing two days earlier, and noticed a smell and called police.

Roland testified investigators found a knife wrapped with Grubbs’ body, a hammer in a trash bag in the apartment, and a microphone stand in the trunk of Gray’s car.

Both Gray and Griswold confessed to the crimes, saying they struck their victim 15 to 20 times, Roland testified. However, he said each blamed the other for cutting the victims’ throats.

Gray and Griswold have remained jailed since their initial arrests shortly after the bodies were discovered.

Two young children of Claybrooks and Grubbs are living with relatives, Roland said.

More Stories

Singing River Smoke-O-Rama is set to return for a second year

More Stories

Local students earn prestigious recognition from Wallace State Community College

Local News

Sound of success: Athens native takes his faith and talent to the Grammys

More Stories

Teacher of the Year: Peyton Boldin

More Stories

Gov. Ivey invites students to apply for 2025 Summer Internship Program

News

State officials react to Trump’s second inauguration

National News

Trump, in his inaugural address, makes sweeping promises

More Stories

Teacher of the Year: Beth Tuten

More Stories

SEDC Board of Directors re-elects LCEDA’s Shockney

Local News

LCEMA: Travel advisory

Local News

ALEA updates on road conditions

News

Limestone County Schools to close Friday, Jan. 10

News

Athens City Schools closed Friday, Jan. 10

More Stories

LCSO arrests four related to storage unit burglary

More Stories

Senator Britt memorializes Alabamians killed in New Orleans terrorist attack

News

‘Athens Strong’: State leaders rally behind city’s rebuilding efforts after tornado

News

Limestone County Schools receive grant from Indiana-based foundation

News

Volunteer opportunity: Storm damage relief

News

FBI says driver in New Orleans rampage acted alone, was ‘100%’ inspired by Islamic State group

Local News

ALEA: Crash claims life of Elkmont man

National

Jimmy Carter, the 39th US president, has died at 100

News

APD arrest man wanted for 1997 Christmas murder

More Stories

Weekend crash claims life of Athens man

News

58 Alabama schools to receive $246,500 from TVA’s STEM Classroom Grant